SPOILER American Idol – Season 9 – Top 12 Girls

SPOILER
American Idol – Season 9 – Top 12 Girls – Feb 23, 2010
Tonight is hits from the billboards.

01.Paige Miles sings: It’s Alright Now (Free)
Simon said, I think out of all the girls you have the best song, but I wouldn’t have picked that song.
Kara said the song was brilliant
Randy said, not the right choice for you, you have a powerful voice, great choice.
Ellen said you pulled it off.
I thought she was okay, not great.

02.Ashley Rodriguez sings: Happy (Leona Lewis)
Kara said that’s a big song, some spots that were not so great.
Randy said to take a chance.
Ellen said take a risk.
Simon said I think you are going backwards, you could be in trouble tonight after that.
I thought she was terrible.

03. Janelle Wheeler sings: What about love (Heart)
Randy said that wasn’t a good song choice for you. I like your voice.
Ellen said you sang that very well, I liked it
Simon said it started off okay, its song choice.
Kara said I like you the song was way too big for you.
I thought she was okay.

04.Lilly Scott sings: Fixing a hole(Beatles)
Ellen said you did such a good voice, I loved that.
Simon said the best we’ve had so far. I’m not feeling any star power from you.
Kara said you’re believable.
Randy said you like a real indie singer, I love the honesty.
I thought she did good but not my type of singer.

05.Katelyn Epperly sings: Oh Darlin’ (Beatles)
Simon said I like you, good choice of song.
Kara said you know your voice very well, she didn’t like her makeover.
Randy said you pay attention to the tone, you can go places.
Ellen said you have an amazing voice.
I thought she was really good, the best so far.

06. Haeley Vaughn sings: I want to hold your hand (Beatles)
Kara said it was all over the place, you have fun.
Randy said I like the unpredictability, great possibilities in you.
Ellen said you shine on stage I enjoyed it.
Simon said it was verging on terrible, a complete utter mess.
I hated it.

07. Lacey Brown sings: Landslide (Stevie Nicks)
Randy said that was terrible, wrong song choice.
Ellen said you’re better than that.
Simon said it was depressing, it was boring.
Kara said it was the song, I hope America gives you another shot.
I hated it.

08. Michelle Delamor sings: Fallen ( Alicia Keys)
Ellen said it was safe for you. You were great and you can do better.
Simon said you did very well. You’ve done enough to get thru.
Kara said there were moments when it wasn’t great. You can get there
Randy said you did a good job but take some risks.
She was again okay.

09. Didi Benami sings: The Way I Am (Ingrid Michelson)
Simon said you are a good singer, but I’m missing a spark here, something that excites me.
Kara said I agree and disagree with him.
Randy said where’s the star factor? so sleepy for me.
Ellen said you do have a great voice, but it was a little low-key.
I liked her.

10.Siobhan Magnus sings: Wicked Game (Chris Isaac)
Kara said I kind of like you on that song. It was pretty good.
Randy said you got a great voice.
Ellen said I loved it a great song choice.
Simon said I liked the song.
I thought she was great.

11. Crystal Bowersox sings: Hand in my Pocket ( Alanis Morrisette)
Randy said you’re one of my favourites. I love the honesty. I like you, I’m a fan.
Ellen said I am a fan of yours too.
Simon said I like you, but there are thousands of you out there. You have to do something that is you. I really like you, you’re refreshing.
Kara said, you were good tonight. You are going to be here next week.
I thought she was good.

12.Katie Stevens sings Feelin’ Good (Michael Buble)
Ellen said it was good, it was great; it was very conservative, I want to see you be 17. It was too old for you.
Simon said I agree with Ellen.
Kara said I think you couldn’t hear yourself, but you have a natural gift.
Randy said you have a big voice; it was just too old for you.
I didn't really care for this song either.

If I had to pick the best three I would have to say Katelyn Epperly, Crystal Bowersox and Siobhan Magnus. The bottom three: Haeley Vaughn, Lacey Brown and Ashley Rodriguez. The truth is none of the girls have really left me with a feeling that says "Hey she's the next American Idol".
My guess at the two going home is: Haeley Vaughn and Ashley Rodriguez.